Our most popular items... Feel the peer pressure!
Feel the birthday buzz from these non-nicotine candles!
$12.99
In Stock
In Stock
A surprise selection of curated Vat19 goodies.
$34.99 to $99.99
In Stock
In Stock
The world's longest sour candy strip.
$29.99
In Stock
In Stock
A massive cube of solid squish.
A little gummy bear with insanely explosive heat.
$9.99
In Stock
In Stock
Three pounds and 4,000 calories of gummy goodness.
$27.99
In Stock
In Stock
65 times larger than a normal lollipop!
$29.99
In Stock
In Stock
A satisfying squish by the slice!
Fruity hard candy with a Ghost Pepper kick.
$4.99 to $12.99
In Stock
In Stock
A colorful donut ready to be squished!
Marshmallows with a crispy coating and candy dipping sauce!
$12.99
In Stock
In Stock
Small but intense bar of super spicy chocolate.
$14.99
In Stock
In Stock
A grossly satisfying pimple popping toy.
$5.99 to $19.99
In Stock
In Stock
A squishy color-changing marshmallow
Mesmerizing massive cube of solid squish.
Five-pound gummy bear is equal to 1400 regular-sized bears.
$31.49 to $33.99
In Stock
In Stock
Fun Fact #128:
The World's Hottest Chocolate Bar and Toe of Satan are made by our fellow St. Louisans at Flamethrower Candy. It makes deliveries easy!
Two pounds of sour and sweet gummy goodness!
$25.49
In Stock
In Stock
A satisfying cube of solid squish.
Tiny neo-magnets for building, fidgeting, stress relief.
$34.99 to $114.99
In Stock
In Stock
A gummy bear just for squeezing!
The world's spiciest lollipop!
$9.99
In Stock
In Stock
The world's most sour soda.
$4.99
In Stock
In Stock
A squishy raindrop with a stretchy base!
A jolly jumbo treat made of solid peppermint candy.
$19.99
In Stock
In Stock
Ceramic mug featuring a built-in cracker caddy.
$14.99
In Stock
In Stock
A squeezable gumdrop!
A plush musical hot potato game with a gassy finish.
$19.99
In Stock
In Stock
10 times the size of regular playing cards!
$11.99
In Stock
In Stock
Addictive bite-sized morsels of awesomeness.
$9.49 to $37.99
In Stock
In Stock
A modern take on the classic kaleidoscope!
$24.99
In Stock
In Stock
A malleable toy that's made for smashing!
A whistle that sounds like a human scream!
$39.99
In Stock
In Stock
Fun Fact #221:
We made an entire horror short film to advertise our Blurry Man Mask. Check it out (if you're brave enough).
Two feet of increasing spiciness!
$8.99
In Stock
In Stock
Transparent putty turns from clear to cloudy and back.
$14.99
In Stock
In Stock
A toilet paper holder that repeats your personalized recordings!
$19.99
In Stock
In Stock
Thinking putty with mind-blowing magnetic properties.
$14.99
In Stock
In Stock
Results 1 -
36
of 36